The Air Handler That Never Went Home
In 2021, the Department of National Defence asked engineers to look for energy savings in one of its Vancouver offices. It was a five-year-old building, already considered efficient, with heat pumps and heat recovery. Nobody expected much.
They found 14.5 percent off the energy bill. Gas use dropped by more than a quarter. And one of the problems they found was simple: an air handler that was scheduled to shut off when the building emptied out wasn’t shutting off. Its controls needed repair. It was running for nobody.
When owners think about cutting energy in an existing building, the conversation usually jumps to new equipment: a new boiler, heat pumps, a controls upgrade. Those can be the right call. But in our view, the first savings are almost always somewhere less exciting. They’re in getting the equipment you already own to follow the people who actually use the building.
A New Building That Didn’t Know It Was Empty
The Vancouver building is the Hoffmeister Building, headquarters of the 39 Canadian Brigade Group. Natural Resources Canada published the results in 2026 as part of its case study series on recommissioning, which is the process of checking that a building’s systems run the way they should for how it’s used today.
The team made five changes. The air handler that ignored its schedule was repaired. A vehicle maintenance area that was used rarely and unpredictably got an occupancy sensor, so its air handler stopped conditioning an empty space. Other rarely used rooms got occupancy sensors, CO₂ sensors and dampers, so ventilation, heating and cooling could back off when nobody was there. The gas heating setpoint on one air handler was lowered so the more efficient heat pumps carried more of the load. And the heating water temperature was allowed to drop further in mild weather.
The measured results: electricity down 15 percent, gas down 29 percent, and energy costs down about $20,900 a year. The payback was 6.1 years, and NRCan notes that most of that came from the new dampers. The fixes that were purely about schedules and settings likely paid for themselves much faster.
Notice that none of this was new heating or cooling equipment. Most of it was teaching the building when to stop.
An Older Building, the Same Story
The same series includes a very different building: a 1997 laboratory block at the Public Health Agency of Canada in Winnipeg, with about 300 staff. The recommissioning provider proposed 20 measures. The building operators picked 7.
The ones they chose read like a list of things nobody had told the building. Cut back air changes when the labs are unoccupied. Lower the reheat water temperature when it’s warmer outside. Shut off steam to the humidifiers in summer. Fix the lighting schedule. Total energy use fell about 14 percent, energy costs fell 8.8 percent, or roughly $59,700 a year, and the in-house team did the implementation themselves. The payback was a year and a half.
It’s a bit like finding the car has been idling in the driveway all night. You don’t need a new engine. You need someone to turn the key off, and a reminder so it stays off.
An air handler repaired so it actually shuts off after hours. Lab air changes cut back when nobody is in.
Occupancy and CO₂ sensors in rarely used rooms, so they stop being heated and ventilated as if they were full.
Heating water allowed to run cooler in mild weather. Humidifier steam shut off in summer.
Two buildings don’t prove a rule, but NRCan’s own summary of existing building commissioning points the same way. It describes typical savings of 5 to 20 percent, with paybacks usually three years or less.
Why This Waste Stays Hidden
If these fixes are so cheap, why were they still waiting to be found? Our answer: nobody complains about a building that’s comfortable at 2 a.m.
Building operators spend their days responding to calls. Too hot, too cold, stuffy, noisy. An air handler running in an empty building generates no calls at all. Neither does a lab getting full air changes on a Sunday. The waste is real, but it’s silent, so it waits.
It can also be hard to see even when someone goes looking. In the Hoffmeister Building, the controls only kept two to four weeks of trend history at a time. The engineers said a year or more would have been ideal. A building that forgets what it did last month can’t tell you what it’s doing wrong this year.
Savings Don’t Stay Found on Their Own
Both projects built in a plan to keep the fixes working after the engineers left. The Winnipeg team’s main lesson was to add ongoing checks on a daily, monthly and yearly basis. That tells you what the people doing this work expect: schedules get overridden, sensors drift, and a building slowly slides back to its old habits unless someone is watching.
The sensors deserve a special word. Adding occupancy and CO₂ sensors, as the Vancouver team did, is one of the cheapest ways to stop conditioning empty rooms. But once a sensor is deciding when a room gets air, its accuracy matters. A CO₂ sensor that drifts high quietly gives back the savings. One that drifts low cuts the air to a room that still has people in it, and that never shows up on an energy report. A sensor that saves energy should be checked like any other piece of equipment.
Look Before You Buy
The practical shift is to put a look at operations before any capital project. Not instead of one. Before.
Three questions are a good start. What does the building do at 2 a.m. on a Sunday, and can someone show you the trend data, not just the schedule? How much history do the controls keep, and is it enough to compare this winter with last winter? And when was the building last recommissioned, if ever? If nobody knows, that’s usually where the first savings are.
What to check first
The air handler in Vancouver is the easy example to picture, but it’s rarely the only one. These are the places we look first in an existing building, before anyone talks about new equipment.
- Schedules against real use. Air handlers, exhaust fans, pumps and lighting should follow when people are actually in, not when the building first opened. Holiday schedules are often never set.
- Overrides left on. A system switched to “occupied” or “manual” for one complaint months ago, and never switched back.
- Heating and cooling at the same time. Air cooled by one system and reheated by another, like running the oven next to an open freezer.
- Outdoor air dampers. Stuck open, they heat outside air all winter. Stuck closed, they miss free cooling on mild days.
- Temperatures that never adjust. Heating water, supply air and room setpoints that stay the same whatever the weather.
- Boilers and chillers. Large equipment running at a small load, or two units sharing a job one could do.
- Pumps and fans at full speed. Motors that could slow down but don’t, and hot water circulation pumps that run all night.
- Sensors. Temperature, CO₂ and occupancy sensors that have drifted, so every decision above is made on the wrong number.
- Trend history. Enough stored data to see the problems above, ideally a year or more.
At Airiva we work by a rule we call performance before plaque: find out how a building actually behaves before giving it credit, or spending money to change it. Existing buildings are where that rule pays off fastest, because the answer is often already sitting in the controls, waiting for someone to read it.
Find Out What Your Building Does at 2 a.m.
New equipment will eventually be part of the story for most older buildings. But replacing a system that runs for nobody just gets you a more efficient system that runs for nobody.
Start by finding out what your building does when everyone has gone home. If the answer is “about the same as when they’re here,” you’ve found your first savings, and you haven’t bought anything yet.
Published by Airiva Inc., an Alberta-based building intelligence advisory firm. No equipment brands or service providers are recommended, and no endorsement is intended.
Sources read: Natural Resources Canada, “Existing Building Commissioning: Hoffmeister Building Recommissioning (RCx)” case study, Cat. M154-204/2025E-PDF, published 2026; Natural Resources Canada, “Existing Building Commissioning: Recommissioning (RCx) of the Centre for Human and Animal Health Building (H-Block)” case study, Cat. M154-167/2024E-PDF, published 2024; Natural Resources Canada, Existing Building Commissioning (EBCx) web page (typical savings of 5 to 20 percent and payback of three years or less).